At a surface level, emotional control, or the power of the mind over emotions, is often discussed as the capacity to manage, moderate, check, or govern one's feelings and impulses. It involves not being entirely at the mercy of one's emotions. This concept isn't new; it's been a subject of philosophical thought for centuries.
Why is this idea of emotional control or management so prevalent? Various sources suggest it's important for a range of reasons. Some see it as crucial for spiritual advancement, arguing that a mind filled with negative emotions like lust, fear, worry, anger, ego, greed, or envy cannot advance spiritually. From a psychological perspective, emotional control, particularly emotional self-control, is considered a cornerstone of emotional intelligence, which can build on underlying skills like self-management. Having psychological competence and a high degree of consciousness and self-control can make for a profoundly liberating way of life. Becoming sensitive to the background causes of one's thoughts and feelings can even allow for greater creative control and help steer a more intelligent course through life. Managing emotions is also seen as important for interacting with others, whether in relationships, the workplace, or society at large. It can be seen as a way to avoid causing harm and to restore communication. Furthermore, in some ethical frameworks, the legitimate and authoritative governance of one's desires and feelings through a higher principle, like respect for persons, is presented as a form of self-governance.
Different traditions and thinkers approach the idea of emotional control in distinct ways.
One perspective, often linked to ancient philosophers like Plato and the Stoics, as well as later thinkers like Spinoza and Kant, emphasizes the role of reason or will in keeping emotions in check. From this viewpoint, emotions can be seen as something that needs to be moderated, constrained, or even subdued or governed by a rational capacity or a moral principle. Spinoza, for instance, describes human "bondage" as being a prey to emotions that surpass human power, necessitating mutual help and the foregoing of natural rights to live together in harmony. He argues that a true knowledge of good and evil cannot check emotion merely by being true, but only to the extent that this knowledge itself acts as a stronger emotion. A key idea is that an emotion can only be destroyed or controlled by a contrary and stronger emotion. Understanding an emotion more clearly can also help bring it more under one's control. Kant, in discussing self-governance, distinguishes between 'subduing affects' (which are sudden and make reflection difficult) and 'governing passions' (which are lasting inclinations and require more stern control).
Another angle focuses on understanding and awareness. Psychoanalysis places significant stress on the emotional life and suggests that a scientific educator should direct attention to emotions. Mindfulness practices emphasize recognizing feelings, such as fear, anger, or despair, and embracing them with care. This recognition and embrace can lead to change and transformation. Metacognition, the ability to reflect on one's own mental states, including recognizing potentially unreliable mental sensations, is also discussed as a way to cope. Emotional intelligence relies on self-awareness, or "metamood," the ability to recognize what one is feeling before taking action. Husserl's ideas on ethics suggest becoming more self-aware and recognizing rational motivation over instinctive or affective drives.
Beyond simple suppression, some sources discuss the idea of transformation or appropriate expression of emotions. Sartre viewed emotion not just as a physiological event but as a type of conduct, a response adapted to a situation with an intention and an aim. While some traditions might emphasize control and suppression, others, like aspects of Tantra, suggest trusting pleasure or allowing things to flourish to reduce or weaken them. In the context of strong emotions like anger, the aim might not be to fight or suppress it but to recognize, embrace, and gradually transform it, for instance, into compassion. Healthy anger is described not as blind rage or resentment, but as a boundary defense that needs to be experienced and understood. Expressing what's in your heart is seen as an art, requiring calm communication, even when discussing suffering or anger. The power of speech can be used to express poison, but also to heal.
Emotional regulation and expression also have significant social and political dimensions. Foucault's work explores how discourse, including medical, penal, and sexual discourse, is intertwined with power, questioning who has the right to use a discourse and how its usage is policed and gains authority. Critical theory recognizes that identity is shaped by political questions surrounding representation. Power is not just repressive but productive, traversing and producing things, inducing pleasure, forming knowledge, and producing discourse. Modern forms of discipline recruit subjects effectively, and since the Enlightenment, "self-knowledge" has sometimes replaced earlier ideals of "care of the self". Affect politics, discussed in relation to Deleuze and Guattari, looks at how collective affects are modulated to achieve political ends, often by activating and canalizing desire rather than simply blocking it. Such politics can be effective because they address individuals on a presubjective, bodily-affective level, suggesting that challenges must also occur on this level. Leaders can be adept at managing group members' feelings to help them work productively and strengthen their commitment to the group. Language itself can be used emotively or distorted for ideological goals.
Achieving greater emotional control or management involves various suggested techniques and practices. Philosophers have suggested strengthening the thinking capacity with will. Spinoza recommended striving to acquire a clear and distinct knowledge of every emotion and associating emotions with true thoughts to become less subject to them. He also proposed framing a system of right conduct or fixed practical precepts to commit to memory and apply to life's circumstances, associating ideas to have precepts ready when needed. Redescription, or changing one's ideas and beliefs, can potentially change how one feels about themselves or judgments about things. Practical advice for managing emotions in conflict includes taking time-outs, deep breathing, and avoiding making major decisions when feeling intense emotions. Mindfulness techniques like focusing on breath or body sensations are suggested for handling strong emotions and stopping unproductive thinking. Engaging in physical activity like jogging or even yelling can also be ways to manage anger. Cultivating feelings supportive of virtue and moderating or extinguishing those opposed is described as a practice involving rational evaluation and affective education. This process can involve contemplating a higher principle or value, like the dignity of the law or the absolute value of persons, to gain evaluative distance from felt attachments. Nietzsche suggests treating emotions as something to be used strategically, knowing how to employ their "stupidity" and their "fire" and remaining master of one's virtues. The ancient Greeks, in their practices of "care of the self," used concepts like _chresis_ (use of pleasures), _enkrateia_ (self-mastery through struggle), and aimed for _sophrosyne_ (moderation, freedom, mastery).
However, the path of emotional control is not without its challenges and complexities. While control is often presented positively, simply trying to suppress feelings can be problematic; lifelong repression, for example, can undermine health. Repression, often unconscious, is distinct from refraining, which involves holding emotions to express them at the right moment. Coolness or detachment in a crisis can sometimes lead to apathy. Emotions are intimately tied to the body, which might serve to signal the sincerity of emotional expressions. There's also the potential for "sham emotions," where one simulates a feeling without genuinely experiencing it. Kant's descriptions of governing passions using "military" language contrast with the idea of a "gentle governor" who reasons with feelings, highlighting the intensity and difficulty of dealing with entrenched emotions. If the environment doesn't allow for feelings to be safely experienced, children may lose tender feelings and become stuck in immaturity.
To sum up, emotional control, as discussed across these sources, involves various strategies for managing our internal emotional states. It is seen as beneficial for personal well-being, moral development, relationships, and even navigating social and political landscapes. Approaches range from classical philosophical ideas of rational mastery and ethical governance to psychological concepts of self-awareness and regulation, and more recent perspectives on transforming and appropriately expressing emotions within social and political contexts. It's a complex undertaking, requiring awareness, practice, and often a conscious effort to understand and guide one's emotional life rather than simply being swept away by it.
Further ideas to explore might include delving deeper into the historical relationship between reason and emotion in philosophy, examining the different conceptions of power and discourse in critical theory, understanding the psychological mechanisms of repression and suppression versus refraining, or exploring the specific techniques of mindfulness and somatic practices for emotional regulation.